Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Mammogram of Not?

As I am getting close to certain age, the question keeps floating up in the chaotic pool of thoughts, mixed up with what to wear and what to eat for dinner. I pushed it down to the bottom and it just keeps on resurfacing. So should I do it or not, or should I do it now or wait for ten more years?

Couple of years ago, one of the friend died from breast cancer. She was one of those sweet and plump lady with a big heart. I always think of her whenever I see certain dishes that she used to make and made it so well...

Back to the topic, mammogram or not? Maybe yes. Let's look at the science aspect. Mammogram is the X-ray picture of the breast. A positive result tell us that whether there is any lump or abnormal tissues in the breast. By getting screened early, we get diagnosed and treated early before the cancer cells spread, therefore we reduce our risk of death from breast cancer. 

Risks are related to chances. So what exactly is the chance that a mammogram will save my life? Let's start with very basic facts. Based on the recent scientific study, 12.4 percent of women born in the United States today will develop breast cancer at some time during their lives. Sound scary, right? Fortunately, Asian women are less likely to develop breast cancer. However, the likelihood is only about 80 vs 120 between Chinese-america and Caucasian women.  So let's say, I am fortunate to be in a group that only 8% of the us would have breast cancer some time during the rest 40 years. Without getting tested, this 8% is going to haunt me with all its mysterious probabilities.

Now let's say I get the mammogram, knowing that at any time, 0.8% of women getting tested have cancer at that moment. In addition to that, there are also chances that the mammogram is not a perfect indication. If I have cancer, there is 90% chance that the mammogram will be right. Which means that there are 10% chance it won't be able to detect and I could go home with cancer but not knowing the truth. And worst yet, if I don't have cancer, there is 7% chance that the mammogram will send me to a emotional roller coaster of dying or not dying. I would think that I would die and then found out month later that I won't die of cancer for a long while. 

Given that, it is still beneficial to get out of the 8% curse, even if it is just temporarily. So what is the chance I will have breast cancer if my mammogram comes back positive? I though it would be 90%, right? Because the accuracy of the machine to detect real cancer case is 90%. While, I was wrong. The correct answer is 9%, which means that even if my test showed that I have cancer, there is only 9% chance that I actually have cancer. Why? There is simple mathematics behind it and I can explain later. But the point is that I would need to be tested, cut, biopsied, and diagnosed further. I would have to go through shock, deny, doubt, and then finally back to normal. Is it worth it?

While then after all that discussion, I am going to do it. Just because all the probability is giving me such a headache already. Even the chance of a mammogram saving my life is so so so slim.


Why only 9%?

I am going to get the first mammogram. To know what kind of water I am treading into, I researched a little. Now I know 0.8% of women getting tested have cancer, and of course it is great to know whether I have cancer or not right now. However, mammogram is not a perfect indication yet. If I have cancer, there is 90% chance that the mammogram machine would give positive results. In addition to that, it could also be wrong even if I don't have cancer. So there is 7% chance that the mammogram will show positive even if I am perfectly healthy. So suppose my test result is positive, what is the chance that I have breast cancer?

At first I thought it was 90%. But actually, it is not.

Here is the math. Now suppose I was tested with 999 other women, total 1000. Now we know by average, there are eight of us currently have cancer. Now we group these eight women into cancer group, and the rest of us goes to health group, except I don't know which group I would be in. Among the cancer group, 90% will have positive mammogram, so seven women will be identified with cancer. Among the healthy group, given that the machine could be wrong at 7% of the time, 69 women will be identified as well. So if I have a report with positive result, I am among the 76 women who is identified with cancer by machine. Among us, only 7 actually are cancer patient. So, my chance of having cancer with a positive mammogram is only 7 over 76, or 9%.